Equally Consider This - 1419 Words

In Peter Singer’s All Animals are Equal, he presents an argument for equal consideration for members of nonhuman species, otherwise known as animals. In this paper, I will argue that Singer’s argument does not prove that animals are deserving of equal consideration because it contains a premise that is not obviously true. The premise I believe to be inadequately supported is the premise that there is no property that all human sentient creatures have that not all sentient creatures have that would explain why the interests of human sentient creatures ought to be given equal consideration even though it is not true that the interests of all sentient creatures ought to be given equal consideration. II. In his argument, Singer states his thesis as the following: â€Å"We should extend to other species the basic principle of equality that most of us recognize should be extended to all members of our own species† (Singer 171). He goes on to explain that by â€Å"the basic principle of equality† he is referring to equality of consideration (172). Understanding that equality of consideration for different beings may potentially lead to different treatment and different rights amongst them, his argument remains uncompromised based on the fact that equality of consideration â€Å"from one group to another does not imply that we must treat both groups in exactly the same way, or grant exactly the same rights to both groups† (172). His argument is not for all sentient creatures to be endowed withShow MoreRelatedMathenys Views on Ulitarianism and Factory or Farm Animals860 Words   |  3 PagesIn this paper I will explain in detail the premises of Matheny’s view and his argument of refraining from eating the product from factory farms, and then offer an objection to it. Matheny states in â€Å"Utilitarianism and Animals† that we should refrain from eating the products from factory farms. The first premise of Matheny’s argument is the principle of equal consideration of interests. To be fair, just, and benevolent, any ethical rule we adopt should respect this principle. The second premiseRead MoreA Debate of the Death Penalty Essay1242 Words   |  5 Pagessubjective term. The value of something, in this case the value of a life, is not determined by external circumstances or the opinions of other people. The outside factors and conditions are irrelevant. Rather, the value is determined by how that person perceives his or her own life and these future experiences. Thus, when someone is killed, he or she is deprived of all the things that were of value and will be of value to him or her in the future. Causing this loss of a valuable future is ultimatelyRead MoreWhether or Not Quotas for Job Applicant Selection Are a Solution to Racial I nequality in the United States1470 Words   |  6 PagesIn this essay I will consider whether or not quotas for job applicant selection are a solution to racial inequality in the United States of America. In considering this subject I will rely on In Defense of Quotas by James Rachels who argues that the use of Quotas is justifiable in certain circumstances. First I will qualify my use of the word race and clarify what I mean when I reference racial equality. Then I will present an argument that quotas will not work as the sole solution to racial inequalityRead MoreEssay about Women and Buddhism618 Words   |  3 PagesBuddha raised several doctrines and explained the theory in a more proper way. The â€Å"Five Blocks† theory can be summarized as women can’t achieve enlightenment because women are weak, jealous, annoying, desiring and having more affairs in the world. This theory makes women inferior to men for a long time. â€Å"Accordingly women are seen as a weaker sex, cannot make a decision on their own, and they are dependent beings. As commodity, they must be taken care of by their parents when young, by their husbandsRead MoreNon Fiscal Barriers And The Free Movement Of The European Union1325 Words   |  6 PagesThis question concerns non-fiscal barriers to the free movement of goods in the European Union. Issues concerning Articles 34,35 or 36 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) are raised and Brian’s potential claim is against France as the Member State who has enacted measures which may restrict imports and exports, thereby violating the Treaty. Firstly, considering the licence required by French legislation to import PS’s, this could amount to a selling arrangement which isRead MoreThe Value Of Information Structure1011 Words   |  5 PagesIn this article â€Å"The Value of Information Structure in Zero-sum Games with lack of Information on One Side† is study showing the probability of two –players in a zero-sum game, which, one lack information, and the other side is well informed about the information in hand. However, it is within each player hand to identify what their choices are, and chose a direction that they would like to take action. Next, it is recommend that the player understand the value of the corresponding zero-sum gameRead MorePotential Employees With Diverse Lifestyles Into The Workforce Essay1524 Words   |  7 Pagesfor organizations† (Von Bergen, Soper, Parnell, 2005, p. 1). With this in mind, this module two case assignment will be composed of a study which articulates the importance of incorporating potential employees with diverse lifestyles into the workforce. In addition to, conversing about strategies for selecting and recruiting a distinct group of potential employees with differing lifestyles in the workforce. Additionally, this paper will distinguish different methods that could be exploited uponRead MoreBuilding A Fundraising Strategic Plan Essay1479 Words   |  6 Pagesstatement function is to guide managers to develop agency’s plans based on its values and vision, it involves fidelity, consistency, legacy, leading, planning, efficiency, effeteness and many others characteristics. In general, there are many elements to consider when managers create a fundraising Strategic Plan. The five major principles that compromise an agency’s strategic plan are discussed in the following paragraphs. First, the description of the mission and the vision. The definition of the missionRead MoreCultural Relativism : A Moral Theory1676 Words   |  7 Pageseconomic, or cultural activities. Their role was mainly to cook and take care of the children. For many of us this is not morally correct since most of us in western societies consider that women should have the same rights as men have. However, according to cultural relativism the ideals of the Patriarchal society wouldn t be morally wrong since morality is relative to what each society considers it s guiding ideals, even if that includes the discrimination of women. Cultural relativism is a threatRead MoreAtticus s Choice For Defend Tom Robinson1395 Words   |  6 PagesWhen examining the morality of an action, one must consider several factors, including the consequences, intentions, intrinsic nature of the act, and the beneficial or harmful effects the action has on others. The classic film, To Kill A Mockingbird, depicts several instances where a character’s actions may be perceived as morally wrong, based on the fundamental principles of ethical theories. In the following, I will discuss the case where Atticus makes a choice to defend Tom Robinson, and I will